At
a meeting last week, the West Sussex Standing Advisory Committee for
Religious Education (SACRE) rejected an application by Mid Sussex
resident Andrew Edmondson to join the committee.
Mr Edmondson, a
former teacher and founder of Mid Sussex Freethinkers, applied to join
the committee to represent non-religious parents and residents, and
promote the inclusion in RE of secular philosophies such as Humanism,
which government advice recommends should be taught to make the subject
inclusive of all children.
Mr Edmondson's application was
supported by the British Humanist Association (BHA), the national body
representing the non-religious.
BHA education officer Andrew
Copson commented: "Humanists have made a significant contribution to RE
over the last few decades, whether as individual teachers or advisers
or through the BHA's own education work.
"It is sad that West
Sussex SACRE does not seem to have recognised this and has missed an
opportunity to take an inclusive approach. If RE is to be a meaningful
subject for all, then those whose values are not religious must be
included."
Humanists believe people can lead good lives without
religion and use reason to explain the world and solve problems. They
believe everyone should be free to live by the religion or philosophy
of their choice if it causes no harm to others.
At the SACRE
meeting, representatives of the Church of England and teachers
supported Mr Edmondson joining the committee. But representatives of
the local authority and minority religions including Baptists, Baha'is,
Roman Catholics and Quakers voted against.
Mr Edmondson, who
lives in Balcombe, said: "The Qualifications and Curriculum Authority
and many other national organisations endorse the inclusion of Humanism
in RE in order to provide a broad and balanced curriculum.
"Seventeen
per cent of people in West Sussex said they were not religious in the
2001 census – that's higher than the national average and more than ten
times the number of Buddhists, Jews, Muslims and Sikhs combined – they
are being failed by the system."
Cllr Margaret Collins, chairman
of SACRE, said: "Following a lengthy debate lasting three meetings,
including a presentation from a Humanist, SACRE decided by a majority
vote not to include a non religious organisation within its membership."
A
WSCC spokesperson added that secondary schools already included
Humanist views in the curriculum; the SACRE was currently reviewing the
curriculum and would take any government recommendations into account.
Mid Sussex Freethinkers' website, which encourages debate and representation to councillors, is at
www.midsussexfreethinkers.org.uk